Climate conference in disarray after leak of secret plan to shaft poorer nations
Copenhagen climate summit in disarray after 'Danish text' leak
The UN Copenhagen climate talks are in disarray today after developing
countries reacted furiously to leaked documents that show world leaders will
next week be asked to sign an agreement that hands more power to rich countries
and sidelines the UN's role in all future climate change negotiations. The document is also being interpreted by developing countries as setting
unequal limits on per capita carbon emissions for developed and developing
countries in 2050; meaning that people in rich countries would be permitted to
emit nearly twice as much under the proposals. The so-called Danish text, a secret draft agreement worked on by a group of
individuals known as "the circle of commitment" – but understood to
include the UK, US and Denmark – has only been shown to a handful of countries
since it was finalised this week. The agreement, leaked to the Guardian, is a departure from the Kyoto
protocol's principle that rich nations, which have emitted the bulk of the CO2,
should take on firm and binding commitments to reduce greenhouse gases, while
poorer nations were not compelled to act. The draft hands effective control of
climate change finance to the World Bank; would abandon the Kyoto protocol –
the only legally binding treaty that the world has on emissions reductions; and
would make any money to help poor countries adapt to climate change dependent
on them taking a range of actions. The document was described last night by one senior diplomat as "a very
dangerous document for developing countries. It is a fundamental reworking of
the UN balance of obligations. It is to be superimposed without discussion on
the talks". A confidential analysis of the text by developing countries also seen by the
Guardian shows deep unease over details of the text. In particular, it is
understood to: • Force developing countries to agree to specific emission cuts and measures
that were not part of the original UN agreement; • Divide poor countries further by creating a new category of developing
countries called "the most vulnerable"; • Weaken the UN's role in handling climate finance; • Not allow poor countries to emit more than 1.44 tonnes of carbon per
person by 2050, while allowing rich countries to emit 2.67 tonnes. Developing countries that have seen the text are understood to be furious
that it is being promoted by rich countries without their knowledge and without
discussion in the negotiations. "It is being done in secret. Clearly the intention is to get [Barack]
Obama and the leaders of other rich countries to muscle it through when they
arrive next week. It effectively is the end of the UN process," said one
diplomat, who asked to remain nameless. Antonio Hill, climate policy adviser for Oxfam International, said:
"This is only a draft but it highlights the risk that when the big
countries come together, the small ones get hurting. On every count the
emission cuts need to be scaled up. It allows too many loopholes and does not
suggest anything like the 40% cuts that science is saying is needed." Hill continued: "It proposes a green fund to be run by a board but the
big risk is that it will run by the World Bank and the Global Environment
Facility [a partnership of 10 agencies including the World Bank and the UN
Environment Programme] and not the UN. That would be a step backwards, and it
tries to put constraints in developing countries when none were negotiated in
earlier UN climate talks." The text was intended by Denmark and rich countries to be a working
framework, which would be adapted by countries over the next week. It is
particularly inflammatory because it sidelines the UN negotiating process and
suggests that rich countries are desperate for world leaders to have a text to
work from when they arrive next week. Few numbers or figures are included in the text because these would be
filled in later by world leaders. However, it seeks to hold temperature rises
to 2C and mentions the sum of $10bn a year to help poor countries adapt to climate
change from 2012-15.














