Choose nonviolence -- it works best
Nonviolence Is The Right Choice — It Works
Nonviolent resistance is not only the morally superior choice. It is also twice as effective as the violent variety.
That’s the startling and reassuring discovery by Maria Stephan and Erica Chenoweth, who analyzed an astonishing 323 resistance campaigns from 1900 to 2006.
“Our findings show that major nonviolent campaigns have achieved success 53 percent of the time, compared with 26 percent for violent resistance campaigns,” the authors note in the journal International Security. (The study is available as a PDF file at http://www.nonviolent-conflict.org)
The result is not that surprising, once you listen to the researchers’ reasoning.
“First, a campaign’s commitment to nonviolent methods enhances its domestic and international legitimacy and encourages more broad-based participation in the resistance, which translates into increased pressure being brought to bear on the target,” they state. “Second, whereas governments easily justify violent counterattacks against armed insurgents, regime violence against nonviolent movements is more likely to backfire against the regime.”
In an interesting aside that has relevance for our times, the authors also write that, “Our study does not explicitly compare terrorism to nonviolent resistance, but our argument sheds light on why terrorism has been so unsuccessful.”
To their credit, the authors don’t gloss over nonviolent campaigns that haven’t been successes. They give a clear-eyed assessment of the failure so far of the nonviolent movement in Burma, one of the three detailed case studies in the piece, along with East Timor and the Philippines.
In some sense, the authors have subjected to statistical analysis the notions of Gene Sharp, an influential Boston-based proponent of nonviolent change, someone they cite frequently in the footnotes. In his work, Sharp stresses the practical utility of nonviolence, de-emphasizing the moral aspects of it. He even asserts that for Gandhi, nonviolence was more of a pragmatic tool than a matter of principle, painting a picture that’s at variance with much of Gandhian scholarship. In an interview with me in 2006, Sharp declared that he derives his precepts from Gandhi himself.
Gandhi’s use of nonviolence “was pure pragmatism,” Sharp told me. “At the end of his life, he defends himself. He was accused of holding on to nonviolent means because of his religious belief. He says no. He says, I presented this as a political means of action, and that’s what I’m saying today. And it’s a misrepresentation to say that I presented this as a purely religious approach. He was very upset about that.”
One of the authors of the study, Maria Stephan, is at the International Center on Nonviolent Conflict. The group’s founders wrote a related book a few years ago, “A Force More Powerful: A Century of Nonviolent Conflict.” Erica Chenoweth is at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard.
This study is manna for those of us who believe in nonviolent resistance as a method of social change. We don’t have to justify it on moral grounds any more. The reason is even simpler now: Nonviolence is much more successful.
3 stars
Greenpeace is another example where nonviolence has worked and been sustained against tremendous temptations to change. The organization was one of the first multi-national non-profit organizations to figure out how to transform and keep nonviolence fresh in a modern media world. The organization is made up of a hugely diverse employee base which represents not only the spectrum of political ideas but also the spectrum of tactics. You have pacifists working next to environmentalists, and you have vegetarians working next to meat eaters. Some of the environmentalists are also pacifists while some would take a more confrontational path. Some of the pacifists are interested in saving the environment but many see ending war to be the most pressing issue. Mix into that women's issues, animal rights issues, minority issues, economic justice issues and one realizes quickly that there is as much disagreement within Greenpeace as their is agreement. Yet the organization has maintained a strict adherence to nonviolence -resisting both internal and external pressures - and the group has to be credited with remaking protest movements. Much of what follows Greenpeace looks completely different from the protest movements that proceeded them. business management degree | criminal justice degree | buy degree
Many people who reject nonviolence reject it because it is too much of a burden to try to treat people nicely in all aspects of your life. In the same way many people who reject vegetarianism reject it because of the universal prohibition against eating meat. You hear people all the time say "I am vegetarian at home but at work or when I travel I eat meat." Vegetarianism in all parts of their lives seems to be too much of a burden. In the same way, people who reject nonviolence in all aspects of their lives reject it because it places a huge burden on them. They might say "I'd never treat my dog that way" but then they turn around and treat somebody else that way. They may be nonviolent at home, or among their circle of friends, but to the larger population they still want to behave in ways that violate the the principles I outlined earlier. computer science degree | Corllins University
I think that more people should know the effects that drugs have on people and the planet. If someone is addicted to a drug they will do anything to get more of it. That is why more people should support drug rehab as it helps return these people back to a happy, healthy and productive life,
Nonviolence is more successful. I agree with that. There are a lot of nonviolence struggle that can be examples. One example of peaceful struggle with a brilliant fruition is the struggle of Mahatma Gandhi. My favorite character, who is, fighting for the independence of his people, by the way of peace. He did not call for his followers adopted the weapon, but instead took his followers to run the action 'without violence', which if not mistaken, its name 'Ahimsa'. From religious leaders, there is Jesus Christ, to teach love. In the end, a great religion, too. So, it is true nonviolence is the best way. How to Lose Weight
Some things I got from nonviolence Role of nonviolence for resolving the conflicts : Not only Gandhians but perhaps 90 to 95 per cent of the human beings want to live in a peaceful world. They are against violence. But some bad elements and some vested interests want to perpetuate violence. Peace lovers have a tough job. Yet one can not give up. We have to take some steps to counter the violence. Peace and non-violence in school curriculum : The older generation seems to be overwhelmed and helpless to face the challenge of violence. We should inculcate the values of peace and nonviolence in the children from school level by making these subjects part of curriculum. The media - especially the television provides too many programmes glorifying or justifying violence. There has to be some restriction of such programmes. For children spend too much time watching the T.V. restaurante madrid
I agree with you so much. We need to get away from violence all the way. We need to get the middle east back in order. texas mesothelioma attorneys
I have to say that I find it a bit amusing that they would have to do a study to come to this conclusion. It only makes sense that non-violent would be much more effective than violent ones. Violent ones only end in more trouble. cheap textbooks
I've never understood people who think that violent protests are going to get them anywhere. Violence does nothing but breed more violence and end up with more trouble. You can't communicate anything with violence, except your idiocy. San Francisco Web Design
I must say that I'm surprised, as I thought that Ghandi was the "all non-violent" type because of religion or something. To see that that actually had nothing to do with it takes me aback some. boat yard ft lauderdale
Love how your article flown. Also, this blog is a GREAT resource for carbon energy. Appreciate all the hard work you put into it!
I will never understand people who think that violence is the answer. Look at what people in the world are teaching our kids today.
Well He was accused of holding on to nonviolent means because of his religious belief. He says no. He says, I presented this as a political means of action, and that’s what I’m saying today. And it’s a misrepresentation to say that I presented this as a purely religious approach. He was very upset about that. learn futures trading
Excellent topics. I really like this topics, I found this from online that, each recipe has been tested and each one has come out perfect If not, they are not added to the site. All you need to know is how to make the perfect dishes.
non violence is the only way to go, if you ever expect public credibility and acceptance, Daveg printable sudoku
printable sudoku
It may be true that you get more legitimacy with non violence but you can still get it with voilent campaigns. The IRA were feted in the US even during there bloody bombing campaigns. If the countries need debt solutions they will definetly help violent campaigners as well. Some peacful nations also use violence as we saw in greece with the eurodebt crisis. Thanks from cute pick up lines and funny groom speeches
It may be true that you get more legitimacy with non violence but you can still get it with voilent campaigns. The IRA were feted in the US even during there bloody bombing campaigns.
They give a clear-eyed assessment of the failure so far of the nonviolent movement in Burma movers moving companies moving quotes local movers
Our website is making a great promotion now. There are many preferential ugg boots . At present , hot sale ugg classic boots such as: Snow Boots | UGGs On Sale | UGG Australia Boots | UGG Classic Boots UGG Gaviota | UGG Gaviota Boots UGG Swell Tall | UGG Swell Tall Boots UGG Roseberry | UGG Roseberry Boots UGG Brookfield Tall | UGG Brookfield Tall Boots UGG Stella | UGG Stella Boots UGG Caroline | UGG Caroline Boots UGG High-Heel Tall | UGG High-Heel Tall Boots UGG Tess | UGG Tess Boots UGG Desoto | UGG Desoto Boots UGG Brookfield | UGG Brookfield Boots UGG Smithfield | UGG Smithfield Boots UGG Shoreline | UGG Shoreline Boots UGG Ashur | UGG Ashur Boots UGG Cove | UGG Cove Boots UGG Men's Brookfield | UGG Men's Brookfield Boots UGG Bailey Button | UGG Bailey Button Boots UGG Argyle Knit | UGG Classic Argyle Knit Boots UGG Cardy | UGG Classic Cardy Boots UGG Crochet | UGG Classic Crochet Boots UGG Flower | UGG Classic Flower Boots UGG Leopard | UGG Classic Tall Leopard Boots UGG Mini | UGG Classic Mini Boots UGG Paisley | UGG Classic Paisley Boots UGG Short | UGG Classic Short Boots UGG Tall | UGG Classic Tall Boots UGG Elsey Wedge | UGG Elsey Wedge Boots UGG Infants Erin | UGG Infants Erin Boots UGG Langley | UGG Langley Boots UGG Lo Pro | UGG Lo Pro Boots UGG Lo Pro Button | UGG Lo Pro Button Boots UGG Locarno | UGG Locarno Boots UGG Mayfaire | UGG Mayfaire Boots UGG Nightfall | UGG Nightfall Boots UGG Rainier Eskimo | UGG Rainier Eskimo Boots UGG Sundance II | UGG Sundance II Boots UGG Ultimate Bind | UGG Ultimate Bind Boots UGG Ultra Short | UGG Ultra Short Boots UGG Ultra Tall | UGG Ultra Tall Boots UGG Suede | UGG Suede Boots UGG Upside | UGG Upside Boots UGG Roxy | UGG Roxy Boots UGG Seline | UGG Seline Boots UGG Corinth Wedge | UGG Corinth Wedge Boots UGG Liberty | UGG Liberty Boots UGG Highkoo | UGG Highkoo Boots UGG Knightsbridge | UGG Knightsbridge Boots UGG Bomber Jacket | UGG Bomber Jacket Boots UGG Adirondack | UGG Adirondack Boots UGG Suburb Crochet | UGG Suburb Crochet Boots UGG Boots | UGGs On Sale | Cheap UGG Boots UGG Boots | UGGs On Sale | Cheap UGG Boots UGG Boots | UGGs On Sale | Cheap UGG Boots UGG Boots | UGGs On Sale | Cheap UGG Boots UGG Size Guide | UGG Boots | UGGs On Sale Nike basketball shoes,NBA lebron james shoes&kobe bryant shoes on sale.Cheap Nike basketball Shoes online store,We provide many kinds of NBA Players' Shoes,Such as Lebron James Shoes,kobe bryant shoes,Kevin Durant Shoes,Steve Nash Shoes,Allen Iverson Shoes,Dwight Howard Shoes,Tim Duncan Shoes,Vince Carter Shoes,Team Basketball Shoes,Kevin Garnett Shoes,Gilbert Arenas Shoes,Chris Paul Shoes,Carmelo Anthony Shoes,Please choose one style of NBA Shoes from our online store for free...
Tiffany | Tiffany Necklaces | Tiffany Jewellery Please believe us , we will use passionate service attitude to receive you , until you buy satisfied goods.Baijiang Seating specializes in manufacturing various of puplic seats. Our main products are theatre seating,school chair,cinema seating,auditorium seating andairport chair.With advanced facility and the craftwork. All the detail and processing are kept improving.The seat style focus on the history and culture for different cities
I just needed to say that your BLOG rocks. I will be your fan
I will have to agree with that. Green nation should thrive and help the earth heal and bring awareness to the people and nation.
Louis Vuitton: Huge Range of replica louis vuitton handbags &purse On Sale.Choose from a wide variety of Monogram canvas,Denim and other Louis Vuitton galinsky description, photographs and visiting information for the Louis Vuitton Outlet, Fifth Avenue New York by Jun Aoki. A handbag is one of your best friends, whether, it be a shoulder bag, Louis Vuitton on Sale a satchel or a tote; it is very useful. ... Louis Vuitton Monogram Vernis Animal Coin Purse Red M91389 ... Louis Vuitton has many stylish Lv purses.It is famous for its high quality, unique styles and fashionable designs.Louis Vuitton leads the fashion trend ... Louis Vuitton Monogram Denim Neo Cabby Mm M95836 Louis Vuitton Monogram Graffiti Neverfull Gm M93703 Louis Vuitton Monogram Graffiti Neverfull Gm M93702 Green Louis Vuitton Damier Geant Canvas Messager M93032 Black
great site vigrx
great site vigrx
A non-violent protest is much more powerful than the violent protest. It boast the moral of the people to join the protest. Non-violent protest and campaigns deliver much more message especially to the government and has more chance to be very successful. Non-violent protest also can attract more people to give the protesters support to their campaign. Online market SEO company in Singapore
A non-violent protest is much more powerful than the violent protest. It boast the moral of the people to join the protest. Non-violent protest and campaigns deliver much more message especially to the government and has more chance to be very successful. Non-violent protest also can attract more people to give the protesters support to their campaign. Online market SEO company in Singapore
A non-violent protest is much more powerful than the violent protest. It boast the moral of the people to join the protest. Non-violent protest and campaigns deliver much more message especially to the government and has more chance to be very successful. Non-violent protest also can attract more people to give the protesters support to their campaign. Online market SEO company in Singapore
thanks.................http://wwwtausiahustadzcom.blogspot.com
First, a campaign’s commitment to nonviolent methods enhances its domestic and international legitimacy and encourages more broad-based participation in the resistance, which translates into increased pressure being brought to bear on the target
How long have you been in this field? You seem to know a lot more than I do, I’d love to know your sources!
Join the call for a Green New Deal to create economic prosperity together with ecological sustainability.
Hello! Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained.
Peace and non-violence in school curriculum : The older generation seems to be overwhelmed and helpless to face the challenge of violence. We should inculcate the values of peace and nonviolence in the children from school level by making these subjects part of curriculum. Insurance
Buy cheap Aion Kinah, Professional COOLAION web site is Buy Aion Kinah
This is great article